Weighing the Evidence Was Cleopatra Black

That Cleopatra was an African queen is certain—Egypt is, after all, in Africa—but was Cleopatra black? Cleopatra VII is usually just known as Cleopatra, though she was the seventh royal Egyptian ruler to bear the name Cleopatra. She was the last of the Ptolemy dynasty to rule Egypt. She, like many other Ptolemy rulers, first married one brother and then, on his death, another. When her third husband, Julius Caesar, took Cleopatra back to Rome with him, she certainly caused a sensation. But did the color of her skin have anything to do with the controversy? Theres no record of any reaction to the color of her skin. In whats called the argument from silence, many conclude from that silence that she did not have dark-colored skin. But an argument from silence only indicates possibility, not certainty, especially because we have little record of the motivation for those reactions. Depictions of Cleopatra in Popular Culture Shakespeare uses the word tawny about Cleopatra—but Shakespeare wasnt exactly an eyewitness, missing meeting Egypts last Pharaoh by more than a millennium. In some Renaissance art, Cleopatra is portrayed as dark-skinned, a negress in the terminology of that time. But those artists were also not eyewitnesses, and their artistic interpretation may have been based on trying to depict Cleopatras otherness, or their own assumptions or conclusions about Africa and Egypt. In modern depictions, Cleopatra has been played by white actresses including Vivien Leigh,  Claudette Colbert, and  Elizabeth Taylor. But the writers of those movies were, of course, also not eyewitnesses, nor are these casting decisions in any sense credible evidence.  However, seeing these actresses in these roles may subtly influence what assumptions people have about what Cleopatra really looked like. Are Egyptians Black? Europeans and Americans became quite focused on the racial classification of Egyptians in the 19th century. While scientists and most scholars have by now concluded that race is not the static biological category that 19th century thinkers assumed, many of the theories around whether the Egyptians were a black race assume race is a biological category, not a social construction.   It is during the 19th century that attempts to classify the Egyptians into what were assumed to be the key races were common.  Whether other people of nearby lands—Jews and Arabs, for example—were white or Caucasians rather than Negroid was also part of this argument.  Some argued for a separate brown race or Mediterranean race. Some scholars (notably  Cheikh Anta Diop, a Pan-Africanist from Senegal) have argued for a sub-Saharan black African heritage of the Egyptians. Their conclusions are based on such arguments as the Biblical name Ham and the naming of Egypt as kmt or the black land. Other scholars point out that the association of the Biblical figure of Ham with dark-skinned sub-Saharan Africans, or a black race, is relatively recent in history, and that the black land name for Egypt has long been held to be about the black soil that is part of the phenomenon of Nile flooding. The most commonly accepted theory, outside the Black Egyptian theory of Diop and others, is whats known as the Dynastic Race Theory, developed out of research in the 20th century. In this theory, the indigenous people of Egypt, Badarian people, were invaded and overrun by Mesopotamian people, early in Egypts history.  The Mesopotamian people became the rulers of the state, for most of the dynasties of Egypt. Was Cleopatra Egyptian?   If Cleopatra was Egyptian in heritage, if she was descended from native Egyptians, then the heritage of Egyptians in general is relevant to the question of whether Cleopatra was black. If Cleopatras heritage was not Egyptian, then the arguments about whether Egyptians were black are irrelevant to her own blackness. What Do We Know About Cleopatras Ancestry? The Ptolemy dynasty, of which Cleopatra was the last ruler, was descended from a  Greek Macedonian named Ptolemy Soter. That first Ptolemy was established as ruler of Egypt by Alexander the Greats conquest of Egypt in 305 B.C.E. In other words, the Ptolemies were imperialist outsiders, Greeks, who ruled over native Egyptians. Many of the Ptolemy ruling family marriages were incestuous, with brothers marrying sisters, but not all the children born in the Ptolemy line and who are ancestors of Cleopatra VII are known to have had both father and mother who were Ptolemies. Here is the key evidence in this argument: We are not certain of the heritage of Cleopatras mother or her paternal grandmother. We just dont know for sure who those women were. Historical records are not conclusive of what their ancestry is or what land they come from. That leaves 50% to 75% of Cleopatras ancestry and genetic heritage unknown—and ripe for speculation.   Is there any evidence that either her mother or paternal grandmother was a black African? No.   Is there any evidence that either of those women were not black Africans? No, again. There are theories and speculation, based on sparse evidence, but no certainty where either of these women came from or what might be, in nineteenth century terms, their racial heritage. Who Was Cleopatras Father? The father of Cleopatra VII was Ptolemy XII Auletes, son of Ptolemy IX. Through his male line, Cleopatra VII was of Macedonian Greek descent.  But we know that heritage is also from mothers. Who was his mother and who was the mother of his daughter Cleopatra VII, the last Pharaoh of Egypt? Standard Genealogy of Cleopatra VII In one standard genealogy of Cleopatra VII, questioned by some scholars, Cleopatra VIIs parents are Ptolemy XII and Cleopatra V, both children of Ptolemy IX.  Ptolemy XIIs mother is Cleopatra IV and Cleopatra Vs mother is Cleopatra Selene I, both full sisters of their husband, Ptolemy IX.  In this scenario, Cleopatra VIIs great-grandparents are Ptolemy VIII and Cleopatra III. Those two are full siblings, children of Ptolemy VI of Egypt and Cleopatra II, who are also full siblings—with still more intermarriages of full siblings back to the first Ptolemy.  In this scenario, Cleopatra VII has Macedonian Greek heritage, with little contribution from any other heritage for generations.  (The numbers are an addition from later scholars, not present in the lifetimes of these rulers, and may obscure some ambiguities in the records.) In another standard genealogy, Ptolemy XIIs mother is a Greek concubine and Cleopatra Vs mother is Cleopatra IV, not Cleopatra Selene I.  Cleopatra VIs parents are Ptolemy VI and Cleopatra II rather than Ptolemy VIII and Cleopatra III. The ancestry, in other words, is open to interpretation based on how one views the available evidence. Cleopatras Paternal Grandmother Some scholars conclude that Cleopatras paternal grandmother, mother of Ptolemy XII,  was not Cleopatra IV, but was a concubine. That womans background has been assumed to be either Alexandrian or Nubian. She may have been ethnically Egyptian, or she may have had a heritage which wed today call black. Cleopatras Mother Cleopatra V Cleopatra VIIs mother is usually identified as her fathers sister, Cleopatra V, a royal wife. Mention of Cleopatra Tryphaena, or Cleopatra V, disappear from the record around the time that Cleopatra VII was born.   Cleopatra V, while often identified as a younger daughter of Ptolemy VIII and Cleopatra III, may not have been the daughter of a royal wife.  If this scenario is accurate, Cleopatra VIIs maternal grandmother may be another Ptolemy relative or someone unknown, perhaps of a concubine of Egyptian or Semitic African or black African background. Cleopatra V, if she died before Cleopatra VII was born, would not be her mother. In that case, Cleopatra VIIs mother would likely have been either a Ptolemy relative, or, again, someone unknown, who might have been of Egyptian, Semitic African, or black African heritage. The record is simply not conclusive as to the ancestry of either Cleopatra VIIs mother or maternal grandmother.  The women may have been Ptolemies, or they may have been of either black African or Semitic African heritage. Race: What Is It and What Was It in Antiquity? Complicating such discussions is the fact that race itself is a complex issue, with unclear definitions. Race is a social construct, rather than a biological reality. In the classical world, difference was more about ones national heritage and homeland, rather than something wed today call race. Theres certainly evidence that Egyptians defined as other and less those who were not Egyptians.  Did skin color play a part in identifying other at the time, or did Egyptians believe in the heritability of an otherness of skin color?  Theres little evidence that skin color was more than a marker of difference, that skin color was conceived of in the way that 18th and 19th century Europeans came to conceive of race. Cleopatra Spoke Egyptian We do have early evidence that Cleopatra was the first ruler in her family to actually speak the native Egyptian language, rather than the Greek of the Ptolemies.  Such could be evidence for an Egyptian ancestry, and could possibly but not necessarily include black African ancestry. The language she spoke doesnt add or subtract any real weight from an argument about black African ancestry. She might have learned the language for political reasons or just from exposure to servants and an ability to pick up language. Evidence Against a Black Cleopatra: Incomplete Perhaps the strongest evidence cited against Cleopatra having black ancestry is that the Ptolemy family was quite xenophobic—against outsiders including the native Egyptians they ruled for about 300 years. This was more as a continuation of Egyptian custom among rulers than it was racial prejudice—if daughters married within the family, then loyalty was not divided. But its not likely that those 300 years passed with only pure heritage—and, in fact, we can be skeptical that either Cleopatras mother and father had mothers who were of pure Macedonian Greek ancestry. Xenophobia could also account for active cover-up or simply omitting mention of any other ancestry than Macedonian Greek. Evidence for a Black Cleopatra: Flawed Unfortunately, the modern proponents of the Black Cleopatra theory—starting with J. A. Rogers in Worlds Great Men of Color in the 1940s—have made other obvious errors in defending the thesis (Rogers is confused about who Cleopatras father was, for instance). They make other claims (like that Cleopatras brother, whom Rogers thinks is her father, had obvious black features) without evidence. Such errors and unsubstantiated claims dont add strength to their argument. A BBC documentary, Cleopatra: Portrait of a Killer, looks at a skull which might be from a sister of Cleopatra—or rather, the documentary looks at the reconstruction of a skull, since no actual skull was found in the tomb—to show features which have similarities to both Semitic and Bantu skulls. Their conclusion was that Cleopatra could have had black African ancestry—but that is not conclusive evidence that she did  have such ancestry. Conclusions: More Questions Than Answers Was Cleopatra black? Its a complicated question, with no sure answer. It is likely that Cleopatra had ancestry other than pure Macedonian Greek. Was it black African? We dont know. Can we say for sure it was not? No. Was her skin color very dark? Probably not.